Saturday, August 9, 2008

Book challenging

In libraries, especially public libraries, there are patrons who will object to different books being on the shelves. The reasons are generally varied. Sometimes the book shows a religion that a parent might object to or perhaps they don't like the story. Most libraries are well-prepared for this eventuality and there is generally a lengthy process before (if) a book is ever removed.
The first step is generally that a person will fill out a complaint form. At that time, they are usually given a bunch of literature, mostly from the American Libraries Association (ALA) about the freedom of speech etc. Then, the head of the department where the book was challenged (almost always occurring in the Children's Area) will respond to the person.
One such response has been making the rounds lately. It is maybe not the most poetic letter ever composed, but it is well-written and well-thought out and really makes the point that we may not always agree with other people's opinions, but that does not mean that everyone else in their community should be deprived of the book because of them.
I like that this gentleman points out that the woman should be proud that she has passed on her ideals to her daughter. He may not agree with her view point on the subject, but he is certainly not trying to preach his own ideals. Nor is he trying to restrict her point of view just because he disagrees with it.
It will be interesting to see what this woman's response is. If she pushes it further, the library may offer to put other books on the shelves that say that gay marriage is wrong (do such children's books exist?) but I sincerely doubt that the book will be removed without a fight.

http://jaslarue.blogspot.com/2008/07/uncle-bobbys-wedding.html

No comments: